Skip to main content

The baby registry: Pros and cons of this popular practice

Know if a baby registry is the best way to get all of that gear ready for your little one

Pregnant woman on computer.
PH888 / Shutterstock

After the initial shock of finding out you’re going to have a new human in the house wears off, your mind shifts to thinking about all the stuff you need to buy. You start making a list of things, and it grows and grows until you want to cry like a baby yourself.

But then you remember you could create a baby registry, and that will take the stress away. Or will it? Does walking through various stores or browsing endlessly online to create the perfect baby registry help the parents-to-be? Or does it create more stress of needing to have everything you want for the baby thought out and planned earlier? 

Recommended Videos

If you’re pregnant, baby is coming, and you need things like diapers and wipes and onesies no matter what. You’ll need to decide whether those items come from a baby registry or an afternoon shopping trip, so here are the pros and cons of a baby registry to keep in mind.

Pregnant woman standing over wooden crib in rustic nursery
Ömürden Cengiz / Unsplash

Pros of having a baby registry

You’ll get what you want in the proper quantity

You know when there’s a potluck for the holiday party, and everyone brings the same three things, no one brings silverware, and there are enough napkins to last for the next five years? You don’t want that when getting set up for baby. Using a baby registry helps ensure you get what you want in the amount wanted. Most of the time.

You’ll be able to prepare for what additional items you need

Once you have everything from the registry, knowing what else you’ll have to buy will be much easier. Creating a budget to get the rest will be so much simpler.

Returns are a breeze

Changed your mind on the color of something or received multiple of an item? Returns and exchanges are less stressful if purchased from a registry.

You’ll get coupons

You will most likely get coupons to get the rest of your registry. Most stores will give you a coupon for a discount to get any remaining items on the list. If you weren’t a couponer before, you will be one now. Welcome to parenthood.

You might score free swag

Some stores give out little goodie bags to expecting moms as a thank you for using them for your registry. Additional coupons to the store, sample-size items, mini packs of wipes or diapers, or travel-size lotions and creams could all be nice gifts from the retailer.

A pregnant person, sitting in profile, holding a smartphone.
Syda Productions / Adobe Stock

The cons of making a baby registry

You have to be patient

If you commit to making a baby registry, you can’t buy anything until the end date. If you aren’t someone who likes being patient, this may not be for you. Once you sign up and give the information out to people, you have to sit on your hands until the registry closes before you can change your mind or buy anything yourself.

You’re pressured to throw a baby shower

The whole point of the baby registry is to open the gifts at a baby shower. But maybe you don’t want a shower, maybe you can’t afford one, or maybe you don’t have anywhere to throw a party. Maybe having everyone stare at you while you try to lean over to grab the next present while not completely falling over doesn’t sound like a good time. You don’t have to have a shower, but the pressure is there once that baby registry goes live.

You don’t want stuff

If you’re a minimalist, already have a child, have plenty of family members to gift you second-hand items, or just won’t want your house filled with baby stuff, you don’t need to have a baby registry. If your goal is not to have every gadget out there, skip the registry. There are so many things pushed on expecting parents to buy that you will never, ever use anyway, so you could avoid that if you don’t pressure yourself with a registry that you need to fill up.

You want to buy it all yourself

If you want total control of buying the baby things, a registry won’t be for you. Some parents love the idea of being the ones to physically purchase and take home the items in real time. If you don’t want anyone else to be the one to buy the items, don’t make a registry. Instead, ask for cash or gift cards to the stores you know you’ll purchase the items from.

Before you spend days figuring out how to put the crib together, the crib needs to be purchased. Having a baby comes with having a lot of stuff all the time, even if you only have the minimum. You need the necessary items to keep your baby happy and healthy no matter where they come from, so see if creating a baby registry fits with how you want to bring baby home.

Dannielle Beardsley
Dannielle has written for various websites, online magazines, and blogs. She loves everything celebrity and her favorite…
Is your baby done with breastfeeding? Watch for these 6 signs
Clues to look out for that your baby is ready to move on from breastfeeding
Mother holding her baby in bed

When you make the decision to breastfeed, it is a whole journey you and your baby go on together. But as with all stages, breastfeeding, too, will come to an end at some point. It's better to know the clues and tells your baby will give to be prepared for the newest adventure. If you're doing baby-led weaning, these are the signs your baby does not want to breastfeed anymore, so you know when it's time to transition to the next stage of feeding.
Signs to watch for during feedings

The feedings themselves will sprinkle clues your baby is ready to ditch breastfeeding for good. If something feels off about the feeds, start paying attention each time you go to sit down for a session.
Feeding sessions become shorter
You know how long your baby eats at each session. When you notice your baby not wanting to feed for the usual time, you might start to worry they're not getting enough to eat. But your baby cutting down on the duration of each meal is a clue they might want to stop breastfeeding.
Baby skips feeding sessions
This is more than your baby finally sleeping longer and missing a feeding in the middle of the night. If you notice your baby refusing those additional snack time feedings, they may be telling you they don't want to breastfeed anymore. Offer a bottle or sippy cup or solid food and see how they react to taking those options. Once the feedings become shorter and then get skipped, your baby has sent strong signals they are over breastfeeding.
Baby gets more distracted during feedings
Babies love to look at everything and check out every sound, but when it comes time to eat, they usually mean business. If your little one is looking around the room, playing with their hands, or generally more interested in what's going on around them than eating, that is a sign they are done breastfeeding.
Other feeding signs to watch for

Read more
5 natural ways to boost energy while pregnant: It’s not that difficult
How to get through pregnancy fatigue
Pregnant woman on couch experiencing cramps

Any person who has ever been pregnant knows that pregnancy-tired is a whole other level of exhaustion. It's only natural that your body would be extra tired, after all, it's growing a little human being, which takes a lot of work. That doesn't make the sudden lack of energy any less annoying, especially in the first trimester, when you’re not sleeping as much, you may not be able to keep food down, your hormones are working overtime, and your body is using all of the nutrients possible to do this new job that you’ve tasked it with.

In your pre-pregnancy days, if you felt this tired you may have immediately reached for a cup of coffee or an energy drink. But since those are mostly out of the question now, how can you fight through the tired, so you can go about living your daily life?

Read more
Your guide to a fantastic babymoon
Find out what a babymoon is and why everyone pregnant person should go on one
Pregnant woman enjoying a pool

You have so much to do before baby arrives. If it's your first child, you have the nursery to get up, the house to get ready, and all of the first-time parent jitters to work out. If it's your second or third or fourth child, you still have plans to make, like who will watch the other kids during the delivery. If you and your partner want to take some time to reconnect before baby makes their debut, we have your guide to a fantastic babymoon to get you both on the same page as parents and as people.
Babymoon basics

What a babymoon is
A babymoon is indulgent time away, typically before the birth of your first child. The purpose is to relax, get away, enjoy your last days before you don't remember when the last time you slept was, and if you have a spouse, reconnect as a couple before you go from partners to parents.

Read more